Review: Kia Seltos vs MG Hector comparison

The Kia Seltos and MG Hector have shaken up the SUV segment. There’s been huge interest in both SUVs well before they went on sale and the hype is real, because both models have raked up commendable booking numbers since. For the first products from two relatively lesser known carmakers, and in the midst of a market slowdown, the Seltos and Hector have got off to flying start. 

The question is, which is better? To find out, we’ve brought together the diesel-manual versions of each. Prices for the Seltos diesel-manual range from Rs 9.99-14.99 lakh (ex-showroom, Delhi) while the Hector, in the same engine-gearbox configuration, is priced from Rs 13.19-16.88 lakh. We’ve considered the fully-loaded versions of both SUV for this comparison. 

What are they like on the outside?

 

 

You wouldn’t be wrong to think the Kia Seltos and MG Hector belong to two different segments. Because where the Seltos measures 4.3m in length, the Hector stretches the tape to 4.6m. The MG is also much taller and wider, and easily looks the more substantial SUV. And it’s not only the Hector’s size that will draw your attention, its styling is in-your-face, and the combo of the large grille, high-set LED DRLs and low-mounted headlamps give the Hector great show value. You’ll also find a lot more bling on the Hector, and the shiny elements on the grille, bumpers and window line do drive home the point that this is an upmarket SUV.  However, the proportions are a bit off, with the long rear overhang looking more MPV than SUV. What also spoils the Hector’s stance are its 17-inch wheels that look a size too small against the vast body.

 

 

The Seltos has the more balanced design. It’s got the upright stance Indian buyers like, and it is a smarty turned-out SUV. The Kia is not lacking in slick details either. The LED headlights are beautifully detailed, there’s a unique LED strip that lines the top of the grille and, if you look closely, you’ll even see a very premium knurled finish on the grille’s chrome surround. Buyers can also opt for a contrast roof, which adds some more glamour to the look. 

Dimensions
	Kia Seltos 1.5D MT HTX+	MG Hector 2.0D Sharp
Length	4315mm	4655mm
Width	1800mm	1835mm
Height	1645mm	1760mm
Wheelbase	2610mm	2750mm
Ground clearance	190mm	192mm
Kerb weight	1315kg	1700kg
Tyre size	215/60 R17	215/60 R17

What are they like on the inside?

The Seltos’ interior looks sophisticated and is really user-friendly too. The 10.25-inch infotainment screen is positioned high up and in clear view, and, in general, all the controls and buttons are in easy reach. What makes the cabin feel nicer still is the level of quality. Right from the buttons on the steering wheel to the padded panel on the dashboard, everything feels built to a high standard. Fit and finish is excellent and at par with pricier European cars. 

You sit higher up in a Hector and the large windows and low dash not only equal fantastic frontal visibility, but also make the already large MG cabin feel larger still. ‘Large’ is also the word you’d use to describe the MG’s 10.4-inch portrait-oriented touchscreen that’s (literally) the talking point of the dashboard. The screen, which can be operated via voice commands too, is your go-to control for virtually all functions, but the absence of physical buttons for the basics is an arrangement not everyone will readily take to. Still, there’s no denying that it makes the Hector's interior appear future-ready. On the face of it, quality levels are also good, but a closer look at the Hector’s all-black interior reveals some scratchy plastics and a few inconsistent panel gaps.

 

Shifting focus to the back seats. If you like sprawling out at the back, the Hector will serve you best. There’s living room levels of space in the back and the impression is helped by the massive panoramic sunroof that lets in lots of light. An absolutely flat floor and adjustable backrest are also elements that enhance overall comfort. 

The Seltos simply can’t match the Hector on room but you won’t be cramped at the back either. There’s more than enough legroom and the headroom is fair too. Shoulder room is significantly down on the Hector so three adults won’t sit in as much comfort on the back seat of a Seltos. Like the Hector, the Seltos’ rear-seat backrest is reclinable and what’s also nice is that Kia has included retractable sunblinds for the nice-sized windows. What the Seltos' rear seat lacks though is thigh support – it's inadequate. 

What features do they get?

Both the models feature touchscreen infotainment systems and smartphone junkies will be happy to note that Android Auto and Apple CarPlay (coming soon on the MG) are part of the package. As for the screens, the Seltos’ 10.25-inch system is slicker and is free from the occasional delay to touch inputs you’ll experience on the Hector’s larger 10.4-inch unit. That the MG touchscreen houses all functions has its drawbacks too. For instance, you either need to take your eyes off the road to find the relevant tab on the touchscreen or you've to strike up a conversation with the system (saying “Hello MG” gets its attention) for something as simple as adjusting fan speed.  

 

The Hector and Seltos also offer eSIM-based connected tech. Owners can keep a close eye on their car’s health and location, and even set a geo-fence to get an alert when their car exits a defined geographical limit, among many other features. The MG and Kia also boast AI voice commands; though neither works flawlessly, it’s the latter’s system that gets it right on more occasions. 

What is undeniably cool is the option to operate the MG’s sunroof by simply talking to the car. On the subject, the Hector’s panoramic sunroof is ginormous, and is easily larger than the Seltos’ regular sunroof. 

Do a quick analysis of all that you get on the SUVs and you’ll find it’s the Hector with the most goodies. It's the only model here with a powered tail gate, it gets a configurable ambient lighting system, and it features a 360-degree camera too. A powered driver’s seat is something you’d find on the Seltos, but the Hector offers power adjust for the co-passenger too. Front seat ventilation, wireless phone charging and an onboard air purifier (that also dispenses three scents) are exclusive to the Seltos. 

 

The Hector also gets more by way of safety equipment. It’s the only one with side and curtain airbags, hill-start assist and ESC. The Seltos makes do with two airbags only. 

Do note, Kia is still evolving the Seltos line-up so don’t be surprised if the diesel-manual version is offered in a better-equipped GTX+ trim in the near future. 

Equipment
	Kia Seltos 1.5D MT HTX+	MG Hector 2.0D Sharp
Headlamp	LED	LED
Sunroof	Available	Panoramic
Keyless entry and go	Available	Available
Touchscreen	10.25-inch	10.4-inch
Android Auto/Apple CarPlay	Available	Available
Connected tech	Available	Available
Wireless phone charger	Available	NA
Cruise Control	Available	Available
Automatic headlamps	Available	Available
Automatic wipers	NA	Available
Leatherette seats	Available	Available
Powered driver's seat	Available	Available
Ventilated front seats	Available	NA
Rear seat recline	Available	Available
Rear window sun shades	Available	NA
Auto climate control	Available	Available
Rear AC vents	Available	Available
Air purifier	Available	NA
Powered tailgate	NA	Available
Safety Features
Airbags	2	6
Parking Sensors	Front/rear	Front/rear
Tyre pressure monitoring system	Available	Available
Parking camera	Rear	360-degree
Hill-start assist	NA	Available
Hill-descent assist	NA	NA
ESC	NA	Available
Rear disc brakes	Available	Available

What are they like to drive?

A brochure-to-brochure comparison will reveal the Hector as the SUV with the larger engine, more power and more torque. The MG’s Fiat-source 2.0-litre engine makes 170hp and 350Nm of torque. In comparison, the Kia’s significantly smaller 1.5-litre engine makes all of 115hp and 250Nm of torque. However, weight is the great equalizer here. The Kia weighs 1,315kg while the MG tips the scales at 1,700kg. This is part of the reason why there’s very little between the two in flat-out and in-gear acceleration. But there are differences in their engines’ characteristics.

 

The Seltos’ engine is smooth, quiet and the more refined unit here. What’s also nice is that the engine is really responsive at low revs, and the build of power is linear and very friendly. You can feel a step-up in power on the Kia around 2,000rpm, and the engine will also breach 5,000rpm without feeling out of depth. There’s much to like about the Hector’s engine too. While you can hear a bit of clatter at times, the Hector’s engine is quiet by class standards.  The gentle build of power is likeable, there is a fair amount of punch in the mid-range and there’s somewhat of a top-end too. The clutch action and gearshifts, however, aren’t quite smooth as on the Seltos.   

For all its size, the MG Hector is a surprisingly easy SUV to drive in town. The light steering makes the MG feel surprisingly manoeuvrable, the 360-degree camera helps wiggle out of tight spots and the low-speed ride is also well-cushioned. Where the Hector cedes ground is in high-speed manners. The steering offers no real feel or feedback, and that’s unnerving in a vehicle so large. There’s a lot of body movement too, and the MG simply doesn’t feel as well tied down as it ought to. 

 

 

The Seltos is leagues ahead of the Hector in this department. There’s fair weight at the steering, the suspension does its bit to flatten the lumps and bumps, and in the corners too it feels like a well set-up SUV. Body control is far superior to the Hector. At the same time, the Seltos also makes for an easy SUV to drive in town. Its relatively small dimensions make it easy to place, its steering doesn’t need much effort to twirl and low-speed ride comfort is good too, if not quite as cushy as the Hector’s. 

Engine and Performance
	Kia Seltos 1.5D MT HTX+	MG Hector 2.0D Sharp
Engine	4-cyl, 1493cc, turbo-diesel	4-cyl, 1956cc, turbo-diesel
Power	115hp at 4000rpm	170hp at 3750rpm
Torque	250Nm at 1500-2750rpm	350Nm at 1750-2500rpm
Power to weight	87.45hp per tonne	100hp per tonne
Torque to weight	190.11Nm per tonne	205.88Nm per tonne
Gearbox	6-speed manual	6-speed manual
Fuel economy (kpl)	21	17.41
Performance	Acceleration (from rest)	Acceleration (from rest)
20kph	1.05s	1.42s
40kph	2.65s	2.92s
60kph	4.65s	4.93s
80kph	7.67s	7.82s
100kph	11.21s	11.39s
120kph	16.30s	16.40s
140kph	-	22.91s
Acceleration in gear
20-80kph (in 3rd gear)	9.91s	10.13s
40-100kph (in 4th gear)	11.99s	11.62s

Which one should you buy?

The Hector is the larger, more powerful and better-equipped SUV in this duo. And as we’ve already established, the Hector has superb show value, both on the inside and outside. It’s well-priced too for all that you get, and what only adds to the package is the class-best 5-year warranty. 

 

The Seltos might not be able to match the Hector on glitz and glamour, but it still comes across as the better all-rounder by virtue of its superior driving experience. The Kia is quieter, makes for a more confident highway cruiser and is just a more involving SUV to drive. What also makes your money seem well spent is the excellent quality. True, the Kia’s cabin is significantly down on space to the Hector, but cramped it is not. To many, the Seltos’ relatively smaller size also makes it an easier SUV to park, manoeuvre and live with in crowded cities.   

All said, it’s the Kia Seltos that comes across as the more sophisticated SUV, and the one that covers more bases than the Hector.

Price and Verdict
	Kia Seltos 1.5D MT HTX+	MG Hector 2.0D Sharp
Price (ex-showroom, Delhi)	Rs 14.99 lakh	Rs 16.88 lakh
Rating	9/10	8/10
Verdict	Superbly rounded Kia sets the new segment benchmark.	Scores big on size and flash. Sadly, not on driver appeal.

Click here for Kia Seltos prices, reviews, images, videos and more details

Click here for MG Hector prices, reviews, images, videos and more details

from Autocar India https://ift.tt/31s6WL2
via IFTTT